Further Readings
Metaphysics: Causation

Walter Edelberg
Philosophy 403
Spring 2002


For complete bibliographic information click here.

Items marked [R] are on Reserve at Daley Library.

Eliminativist Approaches

Russell, Bertrand (1913) "On the Notion of Cause." (Argues that causation is an outdated concept.)

Blackburn, Simon (1990), "Hume and Thick Connexions." (Argues that Hume was an anti-realist about causation.)

Regularity Theories

David Hume, (1739) A Treatise on Human Nature, Oxford University Press, Bk. I, Part I, section i; and Book II, Part III, sections 1-6, 11, 12, 14, 15. (Written before the Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding, the Treatise offers a more detailed analysis.)

Beauchamp, Tom, and Alexander Rosenberg (1981) Hume and the Problem of Causation.

See also readings under Laws of Nature

Necessary and Sufficient Conditions

Ernest Nagel (1961) The Structure of Science, p. 559-560. (Proposes that causes are necessary conditions for their effects.)

Hempel, Carl G (1965) Aspects of Scientific Explanation, p. 349. (Proposes that causes are sufficient conditions for their effects.)

Scriven, Michael (1966) "Defects of the Necessary Condition Analysis of Causation." [R]

Kim, Jaegwon (1971) "Causes and Events: Mackie on Causation." (A critique of Mackie's INUS theory of causation.) [R]

Laws of Nature

Ayer, A. J., (1956) "What is a Law of Nature" (Argues against the simple regularity theory of laws of nature. Suggests a theory of the form: law of nature = universal truth + X, where X is a set of epistemic factors.) [R]

Popper, Karl (1967), "A Revised Definition of Natural Necessity," British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 18, 316-321. [Proposes an account of the form: law of nature = universal truth + X], where X is a matter of satisfying a non-deducibility requirement.]

Michael Tooley (1977) “The Nature of Laws” (Criticizes a number of theories of natural laws. Proposes a theory on which causal relations are contingent relations among universals.) [R]

Skyrms, Brian (1977) "Resiliency, Propensities, and Causal Necessity." (Proposes a theory of laws of the form: law of nature = universal law + X, where X concerns the kind of evidence available.)

Armstrong, David (1983) What is a Law of Nature? (Contains an excellent critical discussion of regularity theories of natural law. Proposes a theory on which causal relations are contingent relations among universals.)

Tooley, Michael (1987) Causation, Oxford University Press, Parts I-II, pp. 1-169. (Contains an excellent critical discussion of the regularity theories of natural law and their variants. Proposes a theory on which causal relations are contingent relations among universals. Argues for differences between his own account and that of Armstrong (1983).)

Tooley, Michael (1990), "Causation: Reductionism versus Realism," sections 1-2. (The first two sections of the paper contain a summary of some of the leading objections to regularity theories of natural law and their variants.) [R]

Probabilistic Theories

Frederick Suppes (1984) “Conflicting Intuitions about Causality" [R]

Cartwright, Nancy (1979) "Causal Laws and Effective Strategies" [R]

Process Theories

Salmon, Wesley (1980) "Causality: Production and Propagation" [R]

Salmon, Wesley (1984) Scientific Explanation and the Causal Structure of the World, , Princeton University Press.

Counterfactual Theories

Lewis, David (1986), "Postscripts to ‘Causation,’" in Philosophical Papers, Vol II, Oxford University Press, 172-213. [R]

Bennett, Jonathan (1987) "Event Causation: The Counterfactual Analysis" [R]

Horwich, Paul (1987) "Lewis’s Program" [R]

Menzies, Peter (1989) "Probabilistic Causation and Causal Processes"

Singularist Theories

Ducasse, C. J (1926) "On the Nature and the Observability of the Causal Relation"

Tooley, Michael (1987), "Laws and Causal Relations" [R]

Tooley, Michael (1987) Causation

Tooley, Michael (1990), "Causation: Reductionism versus Realism" [R]


Last modified on January 3, 2002