Session 2 Definitions, conceptualizations of maltreatment. Similarities and differences between types of family violence. Cross-cultural issues. Issues in the prediction of dangerousness.
 

Theories contributing to knowledge:
 


 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
  David Levinson's study of violence in 90 societies: wife beating, husband beating, physical child punishment, sibling fights
 
  • LIFESPAN PERSPECTIVE (table 2.1, p.26)

  •  
      • infancy: low incident rate in all cultures, based on liability to group

      •  
        • 60% by M, with great pain

        •  
        • reasons:

        •  
          • illegitimate
          • deformed
          • abnormal birth (eg. twins)
          • unwanted (wrong sex--girl)

          •  
      • childhood. most types of child violence occurs only in a few societies 

      •  
        • 26% of societies studied never used physical punishment

        •  
        • sibling fighting occurs in only 44% of societies studied 

        •  
      • adolescence

      •  
        • adolescence not universal

        •  
        • initiation ceremonies in 55% of societies

        •  
        • genital operations in 47% of societies

        •  
          • Note: circumcision and clitorectomy serve very different social functions

          •  
      • adulthood

      •  
        • wifebeating most common form of violence, 

        •  
        • occurring sometimes in 85% of all societies; 

        •  
        • in 100% of couples in 19% of societies (prescribed wifebeating)

        •  
        • husband-beating occurs only in cultures where wifebeating does not occur

        •  
      • old age

      •  
        • killed due to age in 21% of societies

        •  
  • Conclusions of study

  •  
    • Only a few forms of family violence are common in the world: wifebeating, physical punishment of children, and sibling fights

    •  
    • Adult women are most likely to be the victims of violence, while adult men are most likely to be perpetrator and least likely to be victim

    •  
    • Most people in the world have experienced or witnessed family violence

    •  
    • Wifebeating is more likely to occur in societies where husbands have domestic authority and control economic resources
    • Physical punishment of children as routine childrearing is more likely to occur in more complex societies

    •  
    • Violence (physical punishment of children, wifebeating, sibling fights) is NOT an inevitable consequence of family life

    •  
    • Male economic control, mediated by male domestic authority and social restrictions on divorce is the best model of wife abuse from cultural data. 

    •  
    • Wifebeating is part of a broader cultural pattern of violence in a community, 

    •  
    • Wifebeating is consistently related to other forms of violence in a culture:

    •  
      • cruelty to animals (eg bullfighting), 

      •  
      • physical punishment of criminals (eg. death penalty), 
        • fighting between adults (eg. boxing), 
        • military glory as a source of male pride, 
        • painful female initiation ceremonies (eg. feet and breast binding). 

        •  
    • Child abuse is unrelated to cultural patters of violence

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Matrix for Organizing Risk Factors for Violent Behavior 
 
Units of Observation

and Explanation

Proximity to Violent Events and Their Consequences
SOCIAL

Macrosocial

Predisposing
Situational
Activating
Concentration of poverty

Opportunity structures

Decline of social capital

Oppositional cultures

Sex role socialization

Physical structure

Routine activities

Access: weapons, emergency medical; service

Catalytic social event
Microsocial

Community organizations

Illegal markets

Gangs

Family disorganization

Pre-existing structures

Proximity of responsible

monitors

Participant's social relationships

Bystander's activities

Temporary communication

impairments

Weapons: carrying, displaying

Participant's communication

exchange

INDIVIDUAL

Psychosocial

Temperament

Learned social response

Perception of rewards/

penalties for violence

Violent deviant sexual

references

Social, communicatrion skills

Self identification in social

hierarchy

Accumulated emotion

Alcohol/drug consumption

Sexual arousal

Premeditation

Impulse

Opportunity recognition

Biological Neurobehavioral "traits"

Genetically mediated traits

Chronic use of psychoactive

substances or exposure to neurotoxins

Transient neurobehavioral "states"

Acute effects of psychoactive substances

Sensory signal processing

errors

Reiss, A.J. & Roth, J.A. (1993). Understanding and preventing violence. Washington DC: 

National AcademyPress, P. 297.