|
South Suburban Economic Development
Project
Project Number: 389
Report Date: UPP 553
Author(s):
This document presents the work of UIC graduate students enrolled in UPP
553, Urban Economic Development Planning and Analysis, and conducted with
staff at CUED. This project was undertaken in conjunction with an ongoing
CUED project under subcontract to the Cook County Office of Economic Development,
the Targeted Assistance Plans Program (TAPP). This program provides economic
development planning assistance to the communities of Dixmoor, Ford Heights,
Harvey, Phoenix and Robbins. This student project was completed under the
direction of Professor Joan Fitzgerald.
Credit Needs Analysis
A major component of the UICUED contribution to the TAPP project is to
conduct an analysis of the credit needs of small businesses in the area.
Students assisted in the beginning stages of this analysis. To date, a
sample of small businesses in the five communities has been selected and
several interviews have been conducted. A barrier to this analysis has
been the unwillingness of business owners to discuss their financial situations.
There are two preliminary findings. Preliminary evidence suggests that
local banks do not make the very small loans that many of many these small
businesses need. The reason is that the banks cannot justify the administrative
costs that these loans entail. Small businesses need technical assistance
in identifying sources of funding and in completing loan applications.
Economic Development Linkages Associated with
the Robbins Incinerator
There are two components to this analysis. The first examines the economic
impact of the construction of the incinerator. The second examines the
feasibility of establishing new businesses that use recycled products
as inputs. Recycled inputs could become readily available once the Reading
Energy Incinerator is constructed in Robbins. Students examined various
processes and technologies for converting newspaper into insulation products,
plastic into home construction products and glass into tile. The potential
market for such products also was assessed. The incinerator could not
operate without a state subsidy in the amount of $300 million over twenty
years. The incinerator will create between 65 and 80 permanent jobs and
400 temporary construction jobs. More than half of the positions will
require employees with college educations. Paper and plastics recycled
at the facility will be too contaminated to be sold for recycling. Further
impediments to plastic recycling include fluctuating market prices and
lack of proximity to potential users. There is little potential for developing
new industries that used recycled materials in the south suburbs. There
is already a dominant company making products from recycled plastics in
Chicago. Aluminum is used exclusively for cans, and the recycled steel
market is dominated by large steel producers or minimalist. Siting of
a materials recovery facility (MRF) in Robbins is not likely due to poor
transportation access and lack of a sufficient input stream due to the
incinerator's use of recyclable products.
Construction Trades Training Program Development
As part of the TAPP project, CUED is examining the feasibility of initiating
a construction training program for residents of the south suburbs. The
options being considered are starting a new program or building from an
existing program. As part of this research UPP 553 students assisted in
conducting two surveys --- one of potential trainees and one of contractors.
The first survey was distributed to about 20 organizations (unemployment
offices, community or organizations, village halls, job training organizations).
The contractor survey was conducted in conjunction with the Chicago Urban
League. It was administered to minority business owners in the south suburbs
and local construction companies. The base of companies was obtained from
the yellow pages and lists of contractors licensed in the five villages.
This survey will help establish the demand for the graduates of the proposed
program. The students assisted in estimating demand for trainees based
on responses (need, gross revenue). Students also contacted minority-targeted
construction training programs throughout the country to identify models
for implementing a new program (or to expand an existing program). The
topics discussed in these interviews included outreach, assessment, curriculum
and job placement. Although all of the local interviews have not been
returned and examined, the efforts to date suggest several conclusions.
African Americans and Latinos historically have been denied access to
the construction trades. There have been approximately 20 community-based
programs developed to increase access to these groups, but few remain
due to union resistance. It is more feasible to build from the already
existing construction trades training program at South Suburban College
than to attempt to develop a completely new program. Youthbuild USA, a
pre-apprenticeship program that has received national attention, combines
training with the goal of rehabilitation to provide affordable housing.
This proven program with an established curriculum can serve as a model
for a program in the south suburbs. Since Youthbuild USA will be developing
a program in the Chicago area, representatives from the five communities
should remain in contact with the organization to lobby that residents
of their communities are included. Survey respondents prefer a full-time
program. Respondents state a willingness to complete remedial academic
work in order to qualify on pre-program testing.
Site Suitability Analysis for the Proposed Construction
Trades Training Program and Recycling Businesses
As part of the feasibility analysis for the construction trades training
program and recycling businesses, an inventory of vacant property available
for redevelopment in Harvey was conducted. The physical space requirements
for a facility that could house the training program and serve as an incubator
for new businesses was established, and sites were evaluated according
to the criteria established. The criteria included minimum of 50,000 square
feet of dividable space, public transportation and truck accessibility,
appropriate zoning and cost-related features. Students conducted a field
study to obtain information on potential sites. Seven sites were identified
that possessed the required characteristics. Further study eliminated
all but two of the seven sites. Color maps of these sites are included
in the report.
Housing Development in Harvey
A housing market assessment was completed to establish the feasibility
of Community Economic Redevelopment Corporation's (CERC) proposal to build
a low-to-moderate income multi-family housing development. The development
would have approximately 120 to 200 units of non-continuous construction.
This project is viewed by CERC as a stimulus to local economic development.
Students conducted a housing market study of the area. The study included
26 municipalities in the south suburbs in order to determine whether there
is a market for affordable multi-family housing, the size of that market.
The study examined whether there are comparable units in the area. A radial
study (in 1,2,3, and 5-mile increments) was conducted to determine population
demographic information (income, racial composition, occupancy and retail
market information, units of multi-family housing, poverty rates, etc.).
A related task of this analysis was to examine whether construction could
be linked to the construction trades training program and the development
of industries using recycled products. The housing market assessment demonstrated
a need for higher quality and larger rental housing units in the TAPP
project area. Public-sector financing is unavailable for the development.
There is little opportunity to link the construction of the development
to the proposed construction trades training program, since construction
would be completed by the time a program could be developed, funded and
implemented. It is unlikely that plastic lumber produced from a new company
started for this purpose in the south suburbs could be used in construction
of the housing development. There are approximately 40 producers of plastic
lumber in the United States, with one of the most competitive, Eaglebrook
Plastics, being in Chicago. The economics of this industry do not suggest
that a new facility in the south suburbs would be viable. There is some
opportunity for linked economic development from the housing development.
Linked developments are likely to include a convenience store and a branch
bank. It is unlikely that the development could create larger spinoffs
or attract new industrial activity to the area.
Inventory of Community Development Organizations
An inventory of community and church-based organizations operating in
the five communities was completed as part of the study. Interviews were
conducted with representatives from known organizations to obtain information
on their organizations and their activities. There is a relatively small
base of community development organizations with which planners and village
staff can work in implementing development projects. There are several
community service and church organizations that provide services such
as food pantries, home energy assistance, emergency assistance and scholarships.
The primary community development organization is New Cities Development
Corporation. New Cities focuses on housing improvement and development
and operates a home maintenance training program.
|
|
|
UIC
Center for Urban Economic Development (M/C 345)
College of Urban Planning and Public Affairs
400 South Peoria Street, Suite 2100, Chicago, Illinois, 60607-7035
Phone: (312) 996-6336 Fax: (312) 996-5766
This website is maintained by Cedric
Williams, Manager System Services,
UIC-Center for Urban Economic Development
|
|