GEM-SET : Girls' E-Mentoring Program : Science | Engineering | Technology
Home
Welcome
Mentors
Partners
Calendar of Events
Daily Digest
Contacts
SET Links
FAQs
Daily Digest Archive

Daily Digest Archive for October 17, 2002

Q: (Initially posted on 10/11/02) FROM MENTEE ALEXIS. K. IN VA
What do mentors think about state colleges/universities vs.private
colleges/universities? Ivy league schools vs. the rest? What is a public
Ivy, is there really such a thing and which colleges/universities qualify as
a public Ivy? If you could only afford to go to one private school, is it
better to go to a private undergraduate school then a public graduate school
or the reverse?

October 17, 2002
A: FROM MENTOR ELISABETH MARLEY-KOONTZ IN TX
Alexis-

The best thing you can do is select the university that gives you the
experience you are seeking (academic programs, extracurricular activities,
type of students, etc...). State universities are often advertised as being
less expensive, but private universities tend to have better financial
packages to offer (because they are more heavily endowed). I would encourage
you to not limit yourself based on the "type of university" but to stretch
yourself and apply to the universities that you would like to attend. It's a
good idea to apply to a "stretch school" ( you never know exactly what the
admissions committee is using for selection criteria) and a "safety school".

Concerning undergrad versus grad schools - that is very dependent on your
chosen program of study. Some degree programs are most highly ranked at
state universities, while others programs have high rankings at private
universities. Regarding funding, some degree programs support research
assistantships, which means that you perform research for a professor, and
the professor then pays for your tuition and a small monthly salary to cover
living expenses. Engineering graduate programs (in the US) use this model,
and you can obtain a PhD without actually paying any money for tuition.



October 15, 2002
A: FROM MENTOR SUZANNE FRANKS:
Alexis, I'll try to answer some of your questions. I think you can
get a good education and a good preparation for life at almost any
college or university, as long as it is the right match for you and
what you want. It needs to be a place where you feel comfortable
and have the opportunity to explore all your possible interests. That's
not necessarily the most expensive, the most prestigious, or the
largest college or university. Having a diploma from an ivy league
school can certainly create advantages in life but you can have
a successful rewarding life in which you make important
contributions without having gone to an ivy league school.
"Public ivys" are those public universities that have gained such
a strong reputation in research, teaching, funding, exclusiveness
in terms of students admitted, etc. that they are considered similar
in prestige to the ivys. (and sometimes are similar in terms of
snobbishness and competitive atmosphere, though generally not
as expensive.) If money is an issue, then I say go to a good public
undergraduate school, because for graduate school, especially in
engineering and science, you usually get paid to be a student and
get your tuition paid for you, so it's a better deal to be a grad student
at a private university than to be an undergraduate there.
**********
October 15, 2002
A: FROM MENTOR DEBORAH GRUBBE:
Go to the best school you can go to for
your major that meets your other needs like cost, location, etc.
**********
October 15, 2002
A: FROM MENTOR SNEZANA DALAFAVE:
There are no strict rules. It really depends on your subject of
interest and on a particular college/university. Private institutions
are, in general costlier, but financial assistance is available.
What you should consider the most is if an institution is more oriented
toward undergraduate or graduate students. My experience strongly
suggests that, in general, a four-year liberal art college is better
for undergraduates. Usually, at these colleges:
1) classes are taughht by professors, not graduate assistants;
2) class sizes are smaller;
3) the greatest interest of faculty is teaching, not research;
4) if research opportunities exist, they are geared toward undergraduate,
not graduate, students.
In many cases, after graduation, students find employment in the region
where their college was. So, if you would like to live close to your
family/friends, you should try to attend a college in or close to the
state where you live now. This is not a strict rule, of course, but is
something to consider.

END