Q: Initially posted October 28, 2004 FROM STUDENT
MEMBER CLAIRE W. IN MN
Hi,
I'm a senior in high school trying to decide where I should
go to
college. Many people have given me the pitch about a liberal
arts
education being invaluable, but I wonder how will it benefit
me as an
engineer? My college dilemma is between three schools: Smith
College,
Carnegie Mellon University, and Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology.
Obviously, CMU has an excellent reputation in engineering, and
RHIT is
top ranked among schools not offering PhD's. Smith has a new
engineering
program, and I really like the school, but question if I will
be able to
get a good job in engineering after graduating.
So, if you or someone you know went to a liberal arts school
and ended
up in engineering, I would be interested to hear your take on
the
situation. Thanks. |
|
November 6, 2004
A: FROM MENTOR CATHIE MANNION
IN NY
One of the advantages of choosing a college of engineering
within a large
university is that you can choose to take courses towards
your degree
outside the College of Engineering in the different colleges
and schools of
the university. For example, you can take chemistry and physics
in the
College of Arts and Sciences, organizational behavior in the
School of
Industrial and Labor Relations, and accounting in the School
of Hotel
Management. Each of the different colleges and schools have
a different
focus and thus the student body is diverse. If you enjoy having
friends who
have interests different from yours, I would recommend that
you consider
seeking admission to a college of engineering within a university.
Some liberal arts colleges have 3-2 engineering programs where
you apply and
attend the liberal arts college for 3 years and then transfer
for 2 more
years within the program to the partner school of engineering
to complete
your undergraduate engineering degree in 5 years. Since students
have
established friendships and often do not want to leave the
college where
they started, some colleges have a combination liberal arts/engineering
program that returns the student to the first college to graduate.
It is good to consider what you think you prefer when applying
to colleges
so that you make an informed choice. If you transfer colleges,
unfortunately some of your college credits are not usually
accepted by the
new college to count toward graduation requirements. This
necessitates the
student extending their college experience by a semester or
two semesters
taking 5 years to obtain an undergraduate degree and thereby
incurring
additional college tuition and room and board expenses.
Good Luck toward making your informed choices!
********************
November 1, 2004
A: FROM MENTOR MAYLING WONG
IN IL
Hi Claire, When I was deciding which college to attend, I
was choosing
between Smith College and the University of Illinois (Urbana-Champaign).
At some level, it was a difficult choice for me because I
knew that
both schools had excellent reputations. My first major was
biology (in
the Liberal Arts School), but I was also interested in engineering.
Smith College at the time did not have an engineering curriculum,
but
students could take engineering classes at a nearby univeristy.
I felt
that if I ended up wanting to be an engineer, I would prefer
a college
that offered both. The University of Illinois had (and still
has) an
excellent reputation in both areas. For this reason, I chose
the
University of Illinois. It turned out to be a good choice,
as I
switched to engineering during my junior year. While I was
at the
school, I benefitted from excellent teaching. After school,
I
benefitted from the school's reputation to help open doors
to good
companies. I believe that engineering majors learn how to
solve
technical problems. As working engineers, we may not use the
specific
topics that we learned in school, but the problem-solving
skills are
valuable tools that are used every day in our jobs. Hopefully,
my
experience gives some food for thought. Best of luck in your
decision!
One more word of advice (for what it is worth): In the end,
it is not
the decision that is as important. Instead making the most
of the
situation that you are in is (I believe) more important. So,
while the
decision may seem rather agonizing at the moment, your hard
work,
perserverance, and williness to try new things will take you
far, no
matter what school you decide to attend. -Mayling
|